Modern SharePoint Pages Done Wrong—Are You Guilty?

Your SharePoint page looks modern, but here’s what most admins
don’t realize: those default layouts and buttons might be
blocking your next workflow breakthrough. It’s not about fancier
graphics—it’s about getting the right data, in the right hands,
at the right moment.We’re unpacking the subtle design mistakes
that kill productivity, and the advanced fixes that even
Microsoft’s templates don’t mention.


Design Traps: Why Most SharePoint Pages Stall Progress


If you’ve worked with SharePoint for more than a week, you’ve
probably seen this: a shiny, modern page that promises progress
but somehow feels just as clunky as the classic version you
replaced. Everything looks cleaner, brighter, and a bit more
“Microsofty,” but after the first login, people start drifting
away. So why does a platform built to drive collaboration so
often leave teams lost, clicking through an endless loop of
lists, libraries, and menu bars? The short answer is: just
because it’s “modern” on the surface doesn’t mean it actually
works for real business needs underneath. Let’s zoom in on how
this plays out day to day.A typical SharePoint journey goes like
this. Someone on IT—or maybe even a keen business user—unlocks
Modern Pages after years on classic. There’s buzz in the hallway
about new templates, better mobile support, and those snappy web
parts. Overnight, your intranet homepage turns from a wall of
blue links into something that looks like a news portal.
Announcements in bright tiles. Hero web parts with cute icon
overlays. You get pats on the back for finally making something
that “looks like 2024.” But within two months, complaints start.
Stats are out of date. No one knows what’s actually urgent. The
site’s prettier, but it hasn’t solved anything old SharePoint
struggled with—except now it’s hiding it behind gradients and
whitespace.Here’s the real impact that shows up quietly.
Productivity tanks. Teams used to go to SharePoint when they
needed to see what was happening—now, they open it, don’t see
answers or triggers, and bounce out. You’ll hear things like “We
put that on the SharePoint,” but then someone follows up with
“Did you check the email?” or “Let me just export this to Excel
and mail it around.” The site itself sits in the background,
collecting project docs nobody opens twice. Real workflows keep
happening by email or, worse, in rogue Teams chats nobody can
trace later.Picture a project status page someone set up with a
modern list and a calendar. The interface looks fine on desktop,
but overdue tasks use the same color as new ones, there’s no way
to flag things visually, and you can’t trigger a workflow right
from the view. The analytics everyone actually wants—for example,
how many tasks have slipped this week, or which team members are
overloaded—are buried in a Power BI report that takes three
separate clicks to open. Over time, that friction adds up.
Instead of one glance to see what’s at risk, someone spends half
their Monday piecing together updates from three locations.
Nothing about that feels modern.Now, Microsoft’s own research has
called this out. They found users start ignoring SharePoint pages
that don’t show actionable items or surface what really matters.
If a homepage looks nice but doesn’t let you act—like assigning a
task or flagging a delay—people move on. It’s a classic case of
design missing the point. Modern layouts try to streamline what
you see, but out of the box, they almost always limit what you
can actually act on. Most web part templates surface static
lists, announcements, or image carousels, but if you try to show
live business data or trigger a Power Automate flow somewhere,
you hit a wall quickly.What’s the business cost here? It’s not
just grumbling in the halls. Delays creep in because teams aren’t
nudged to act at the right time. Missed deadlines happen because
someone thought an alert would show up on the homepage, but it
didn’t. Every cycle, people revert back to their habits:
downloading the latest updates to Excel, forwarding new versions
as attachments, building side trackers nobody else can see. The
company still pays for SharePoint, but all the collaboration and
workflow promises are happening outside the system, in
spreadsheets and inboxes.I’ve seen this first-hand with teams who
try to add more “intelligence” to a modern SharePoint page. There
was a project office that wanted to keep all their KPIs and task
dashboards visible, live, and interactive. They found a JSON
template that looked promising and spent a weekend tweaking card
layouts and color rules. It looked sharp—for about a day. The
moment they tried to surface data from their actual list (like
highlight overdue items automatically), the formatting got shaky.
Web parts started losing connections. A mobile user complained
that half the buttons disappeared on their iPad. No matter what
they changed, something always slipped through. The dream of a
dynamic dashboard faded, replaced by grumpy emails about why
SharePoint “never just works.”At the heart of this, it’s not
about how many web parts you stacked on a page or how modern it
looks. The real miss is not using the platform to automate and
connect business processes right where work happens. If all
you’re doing is making an announcement wall a little prettier,
you haven’t gained much. The power comes from letting pages
trigger reminders, update records, and pull in fresh data without
making users jump between three platforms. So how does a
SharePoint site actually cross that line—from pretty brochure to
workflow engine? It’s not about more templates, it’s about
unlocking the right tools and knowing where those templates hit
their limits. Let’s get specific about how admins are flipping
that switch and turning static sites into active business hubs.


From Static to Dynamic: Unlocking Power with SPFx Extensions


Most SharePoint admins still think about pages as something you
build out with web parts and a few rounds of JSON. But what gets
missed almost every time is just how much you can actually unlock
with SPFx extensions. I’ve seen countless teams hit a ceiling
trying to surface live project updates, automate status flags, or
get anything interactive beyond just reading a list. So here’s
the question: what if your SharePoint page could act on business
processes itself, with one click, no jumping across five
apps?Let’s set the scene. You’ve got a project team moving fast,
and suddenly the requirements change mid-sprint. Instead of just
showing the team a task list, you want them to be able to flag an
urgent issue right there—no waiting for an email, no posting in
Teams, just click, assign, and let the system notify the right
people. Maybe you’re facing a board that needs a quick rundown of
the latest risks, or you have finance managers needing real-time
figures surfaced without leaving the homepage. Using only web
parts and standard templates, you’re out of luck. You can show or
hide content, but as soon as you want to actually trigger
something useful, or have the page update in front of the user,
the platform falls flat.And this is usually where someone gets
the bright idea to keep “improving” the page by layering on more
JSON formatting. It works, until it doesn’t. Sure, you can throw
together a clever color-coding scheme or a few icons that appear
conditionally, but the moment you need the page to talk back—to
run a flow, send an alert, or handle live data without constant
refreshes—the design quickly gets brittle. JSON was never meant
for business automation. If you try to stretch it to do anything
beyond layout tweaks, you’re signing up for maintenance headaches
every time Microsoft tweaks the platform.Let’s get specific.
Picture a project dashboard where every task’s status is updating
as changes happen in the list. Instead of making users refresh
the whole page, or guess when something’s slipped, an SPFx
command set can highlight overdue items in red, attach a “Send
Teams Alert” button, and update the count of open blockers live
as you interact. One click triggers a Power Automate flow,
sending that late task straight to the right channel—with
context, a link, and a deadline. No copying, no pasting, not even
an extra tab. Suddenly, your SharePoint site is running the
process, not just logging it.Here’s something that gets
overlooked: most organizations never take advantage of these SPFx
extensions. Microsoft MVPs have been recommending them for years.
You hear the same advice in every SharePoint community
webinar—field customizers and command sets are where the real
action happens for digital workplaces. But in practice, IT teams
get stuck between “off the shelf” and “too much code,” so
progress stalls. End users keep asking for the same features that
the platform could deliver, if only someone flipped on an
extension instead of fighting layout JSON.So what exactly are
SPFx extensions, and why do they matter? At a high level, these
are pieces of code you add to a SharePoint site to change how it
behaves—not just how it looks. Field customizers tweak what
appears in your lists, letting you swap a boring text field for a
chart, a progress bar, or a live badge that updates when someone
changes the item. Command sets live inside your list and library
toolbars—they add those extra buttons like “Send Alert,” “Assign
Reviewer,” or even “Flag as Critical” with custom business logic
underneath. Header and footer injectors give you persistent
banners, controls, or links across the whole site, not just on a
single page. And the kicker? They work together, often letting
one action trigger something visible across the whole
workspace.Without these, SharePoint is just another interface for
data storage. Users end up clicking through to Outlook for
notifications, opening Power BI for reporting, or—yes—exporting
data to Excel just to analyze what’s going wrong. All that
context gets lost in the handoff. You’ve probably seen it
yourself: a status report gets out of sync, or someone misses an
overdue task because the alert wasn’t right in front of them.I’ll
show you what this looks like in real life. Imagine opening a
list and seeing every overdue task immediately turn red. Next to
each one is a new button—”Flag in Teams”—courtesy of a simple
SPFx command set. Tap it, and the system kicks off an alert with
all the task details, assigns a reminder, and marks the item as
escalated for everyone to see. No inboxes, no extra steps, just
action—right from inside SharePoint. It’s a basic use of SPFx,
but the impact on team accountability is huge. People start
depending on SharePoint as the hub for getting things done, not
just for storing documents.The best part? Now your site isn’t
just a static list or pretty homepage. It’s an interactive nerve
center that notifies, tracks, and responds. That’s the difference
between compliance-driven “digital paperwork” and a system that
actually supports how people work today. But as you might expect,
not all extensions deliver the same results—some are
game-changers, others turn into support tickets overnight. So
let’s talk about what a solid, future-proof extension actually
looks like once you roll it out in the real world.


Building Advanced Layouts: JSON Templates Without Breaking
Everything


If you’ve ever thought JSON formatting was the shortcut to slick
SharePoint dashboards, you’re not the only one. On the surface,
Microsoft’s page templates look like a blank slate for creative
layouts—columns, conditional color rules, icons that show or hide
depending on status. It feels like you should be able to build a
fully custom command center just by pasting in some JSON, picking
a few layout tricks, and letting users have at it. In reality,
though, the moment you start building a more advanced page—think
multi-section dashboards, nested conditional formatting, or
custom grouping—you start noticing the cracks.Picture this:
you’re deep in the SharePoint “Advanced formatting” panel,
layering logic for a list view that highlights urgent tasks,
shades every other row, and shows a star if a project is over
budget. You manage to get something that looks solid in your own
browser. But then a coworker checks the same page on a tablet,
and half the formatting collapses. The nested sections realign in
weird ways, buttons drift to the wrong spots, or web parts load
out of order. Someone else reports that a Power App embedded in
the page now refuses to load. And nobody can explain why what
worked yesterday is now broken after a small Microsoft update.The
reality is, the more ambitious your JSON layout becomes, the more
ways there are for it to fail. Modern SharePoint is always
evolving behind the scenes—Microsoft rolls out tweaks, adds new
column types, or ships a minor interface change—so templates that
once felt stable suddenly break or misbehave, especially on
mobile or low-resolution screens. There’s no warning when a
critical button gets orphaned or a color-coding rule stops
applying. Admins often spend hours adjusting little details—pixel
nudges, JSON syntax changes, displayOrder re-shuffles—just to
keep the original vision intact.Ask any SharePoint site owner
who’s gone “all-in” on JSON, and you’ll hear a familiar story. I
watched a team lead pour two days into a dashboard—carefully
arranging tiles, adding rollup cards, and setting up buttons to
filter their project queue. The next Monday, users started
reporting that the “Add New” button was missing on mobile, while
others noticed the footer bar floating halfway up the page on
Chrome. The workaround? More trial and error, refreshing, and
combing through the Microsoft Tech Community for half-documented
fixes. The initial excitement of a high-impact dashboard faded
fast and got replaced by a steady drip of user complaints.What’s
striking is that Microsoft’s own documentation tends to cover
only textbook scenarios: a list with a single column, some
background colors, maybe an icon or two. But most business needs
venture way beyond that. They involve dynamic web parts, multiple
data sources, workflow triggers, and mobile support that holds up
on every device. The gap between what gets demoed in a training
video and what users demand in the real world is huge.So, is
there a way to push JSON further without setting yourself up for
a maintenance nightmare? The answer usually isn’t “more
formatting.” The real trick is blending JSON with SPFx field
customizers or command sets. For example, you can keep JSON
focused on layout basics—column widths, minimal conditional
colors, maybe a headline bar—and let SPFx handle anything
interactive or tied to updates. If you want a button to trigger a
Power Automate flow, don’t try to fake it with a hyperlink and
icon in a JSON block. Instead, drop in a custom command or field
extension linked to real logic.There’s a practical rule I try to
share: use JSON for what it does well—styling, visibility, and
basic layout. The moment you need interaction, automation, or
dynamic data from outside SharePoint, it’s time for SPFx.
Otherwise, you’ll end up with a page that looks great one week
and needs constant tweaks the next.Let’s look at a real
before-and-after example. One team built a dashboard with heavy
conditional JSON—icons for every status, color for risk, custom
spacing, and even embedded pseudo-buttons. It held up on desktop,
barely, but new hires on tablets complained about glitches, and
every minor Microsoft update broke something—colors, buttons, or
even entire card layouts. Eventually, they rebuilt the core
layout using simple JSON for the basics, but shifted every button
and alert to SPFx extensions. Overnight, the same dashboard ran
smoother, updates shipped without breaking views, and mobile
glitches disappeared. The time they once spent on frantic fixes
got repurposed into building new features.At the end of the day,
knowing where JSON’s power stops—and when to call in SPFx—is what
keeps your SharePoint hub from turning fragile. It's not about
which format is “better.” It’s about longevity and letting each
tool handle what it does best. Push JSON too far and you’re on
call every time Microsoft tweaks a web part. Strike the balance
and you avoid creating layouts that eat up more support hours
than they save.But dashboards and layouts are only half the
story. Many teams hit another wall when they try to pull in live
data from outside SharePoint, automate task flags, or sync status
with a third-party system. That’s where the conversation turns to
integrations and real-time automations, not just layout.


Integrating and Automating: Real-Time Data, Task Flagging, and
External Sources


If you walk through most SharePoint sites, there’s a familiar
pattern: you see news posts, document libraries, and web parts
laid out in tidy rows, but the pulse of the business is always a
step behind. A project manager checks in and sees project lists,
but if they look for which tasks dragged past deadline this week
or want live sales analytics, they start clicking off to a
separate dashboard or waiting for the Excel export to finish.
It’s odd how often real action points just don’t show up—even on
modern pages packed with features. We’ve all heard “SharePoint
can do that,” but what’s actually possible now, and why do so
many sites end up missing the mark?Let’s picture this with a real
scenario. You run a busy project team. The task tracker sits in
SharePoint—every task, assignee, status, and due date lined up.
It’s well-organized, but when a deadline slips, nothing just
happens. The task sits there, bold font or no, waiting for
someone to notice before a client update goes sideways. If you
want an alert to pop up in Teams or show overdue flags in real
time, the usual answer is a workaround: extra lists, manual
refresh, or gluing charts together in Power BI. Most users
develop a muscle memory for this—they scan SharePoint for static
info, then switch to Outlook or Teams to actually move work
forward.It’s not that SharePoint can’t do live flagging and
automation. The default experience just leaves most organizations
in the shallow end. JSON formatting can make a late task turn
red, but it can’t notify the team, or escalate the item, or show
you changing numbers as work gets done. You end up with pretty
status icons, but they don’t drive outcomes. It’s frustrating
because users expect better. If TikTok and Outlook can surface
real-time updates, surely a business portal should be able to do
the same.Here’s where things start getting interesting. SPFx
field customizers and command sets finally break the “static
list” pattern. With the right extension, you’re not limited to
changing colors or adding a tooltip. You can actually trigger
next steps—think launching a Power Automate flow, hitting an
internal API, or even posting a message to Teams from a
SharePoint page with a single click. For example, a well-built
list view command set lets a manager flag overdue tasks as
“critical.” One tap, and the task not only changes color in the
view but instantly dispatches a custom Teams alert, complete with
task details and a deep link back to the list. Suddenly,
SharePoint isn’t just a digital noticeboard—it’s acting as a
workflow nerve center.Now, this is where real business value
comes in. When you pair SharePoint with the Power Platform, Azure
Functions, or even custom APIs, you start unlocking integrations
that go beyond what’s possible straight out of the box. Power
Automate flows can respond to task changes, trigger reminders, or
route escalations through Teams, Outlook, or SMS. Azure Functions
let you tap into more advanced logic or external systems—like
pulling in financial data, updating inventory, or syncing with a
partner’s project plan. REST APIs open doors to third-party data
sources, from CRM tools to industry-specific applications. The
point is, SharePoint doesn’t need to silo information anymore. It
can reach out, interact, and reflect changes from platforms
outside its own ecosystem.Let’s see how this plays out visually.
Imagine a project dashboard front and center on your SharePoint
home. Task stats update as items change—no refresh needed. If
inventory drops below a threshold in your ERP system, a colored
indicator flips from green to yellow in real time. Active risks
or compliance warnings appear for managers, right on the same
portal where documents live. Links trigger flows, show pop-ups
with live numbers, or pull summary reports without anyone leaving
the page. This is miles ahead of the usual “download to Excel,
make a chart, then upload it again” cycle.Of course, adding this
level of integration comes with its own set of watch points.
Security matters. When you connect SharePoint to external APIs or
introduce automated flows, you’re opening up new points of
risk—permissions, data exposure, and organizational compliance
all need checks and balances. Throttling is another headache; API
calls made on every item render or too many Power Automate
triggers can run you into Microsoft’s service limits pretty
quickly, especially if you’re not caching results. Then there’s
update risk—Microsoft changes things under the hood, and a
hardcoded API endpoint or permissioned flow can break quietly,
leading to silent failures or nagging user complaints. It pays to
document dependencies and test every scenario, especially those
corner cases where custom integrations might fail.But done right,
SharePoint becomes a real workflow hub. You get actual triggers,
live data, and context right where the work happens. Sites stop
being graveyards for documents and old news, and instead become
places users go to actually get things moving—assign, flag,
escalate, and review, without needing another platform in the
mix.So as more teams look at these integrations, it’s worth
thinking about how all this plays into business processes and
bottom-line results. Automated alerts and real-time data don’t
just make life easier—they reduce errors, catch risks faster, and
keep everyone moving with less handholding and repetition.


Conclusion


Most SharePoint sites look sharp but stay stuck showing static
lists because no one pushes beyond the defaults. If you’re still
sending reminders manually or exporting data just to see what
changed, you’re missing what these pages can really deliver.
Turning SharePoint into a true workflow hub is about knowing when
to hand things off—from styling with JSON to real automation with
SPFx and Power Platform. Every manual step you cut saves time,
reduces errors, and keeps your team focused where it matters.
Subscribe for practical M365 fixes, and drop your biggest
SharePoint frustration in the comments.


Get full access to M365 Show - Microsoft 365 Digital Workplace
Daily at m365.show/subscribe