43: Coffindaffer On The Challenges Of Multiple Investigations Into Rex Heuermann

The chilling case of Rex Heuermann, the man suspected of being
the Long Island serial killer, notably known as the Gilgo beach
murderer, took center stage in a recent episode of the podcast
"Hidden Killers." Host Tony Brueski, in discussion with former
FBI Special Agent and Hidden Killers Daily Contributor Jennifer
Coffindaffer, delved deep into the intricate details of the
investigation spanning multiple jurisdictions, states, and
years.
 
Brueski initiated the conversation by mentioning a peculiar and
disturbing detail related to Heuermann: "The strange guy down the
road that has creepy dolls in his house." Alluding to a
particularly eerie discovery made at the suspect's residence,
Brueski expressed his apprehension, "I'd still wanna know what
that's going to be, if anything, when it comes to this trial. I
got bad feelings about that doll."
 
However, the central focus of the discussion was the overarching
challenge posed by the vastness of the investigation, spread
across different states and timelines. Brueski inquired, "How
difficult is that from an investigative standpoint to get
everybody on the same page and sharing information over such a
long period of time?"
 
Coffindaffer elucidated the difficulties, emphasizing the
distinction between cases managed exclusively by the FBI versus
those that involve multiple local and state agencies. "It's a big
hurdle, Tony," she affirmed. "When the bureau is in charge of
something, you have one bureaucracy. But when you have dozens,
potentially, of law enforcement agencies... each jurisdiction has
their own level of prioritization." The challenge gets amplified,
especially when investigators from different precincts have
varying caseloads and methods of handling evidence.
 
However, Coffindaffer noted that the high-profile nature of the
Heuermann case would likely galvanize various jurisdictions to
collaborate effectively, given the intense public and media
scrutiny. "It's going to be very interesting. It is obviously a
big publicized case, and I think that's going to help motivate
these jurisdictions to get these cases solved," she stated.
 
Brueski then raised a pivotal question regarding Heuermann's
trial, questioning whether there would be multiple trials or if
authorities would wait until investigations across states
concluded. Coffindaffer's response provided clarity: "I think
what we'll see is what we call a superseding indictment. That
will happen once they have the evidence put together on Gilgo
four." This essentially means that once additional evidence is
pieced together linking Heuermann to further crimes, the charges
against him would be updated, effectively resetting the legal
clock.
 
Drawing attention to the intensive nature of the investigations,
she elaborated, "Recall they have 12, 13 days of investigation at
his house... We have the DNA profile that might link him to other
LISC killings."
 
In terms of a timeline for Heuermann's trial, Coffindaffer
estimated, "I think we're looking way out to the origin of your
question, a year, two years. But they will not wait until South
Carolina, Nevada, and other states conduct their
investigations."
 
With the spotlight on the Long Island killings, it seems
investigators are determined to connect the dots, provide justice
to the victims, and ensure Heuermann faces the consequences if
found guilty. The case, with its multi-state implications and
gruesome revelations, continues to hold the public's attention
and is a testament to the complexities of modern-day criminal
investigations.
Want to listen to ALL of our podcasts AD-FREE? Subscribe
through APPLE PODCASTS, and try it for three days free:
https://tinyurl.com/ycw626tj
Follow Our Other Cases:
https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com
The latest on Catching the Long Island Serial Killer, Chad &
Lori Daybell, The Murder of Ana Walshe, Alex Murdaugh, Bryan
Kohberger, Lucy Letby, Kouri Richins, Justice for Harmony
Montgomery, The Murder of Stephen Smith, The Murder of Madeline
Kingsbury, and much more! Listen at
https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com