48: Did Police Over-Damage Heuermann's House During Raid?

In a recent episode of the podcast "Hidden Killers," host Tony
Brueski dives deep into the unsettling incident surrounding the
family of Rex. Alongside psychotherapist and author Shavaun
Scott, Brueski delves into the controversial aftermath of a home
raid conducted on Rex's family residence by law
enforcement.
 
Rex's wife, apparently distressed by the extent of the damage
caused during the raid, has filed a notice of claim against the
law enforcement agencies involved. The raid, which was executed
under suspicions of Rex being a serial killer for 30 years, left
the home in shambles. The family's valuables were shattered, beds
were cut open, and even drain pipes were removed from the
bathroom sink rendering it unusable.
 
Brueski remarked, "This is interesting and I wanna look not just
at the complaint of this, of, oh my gosh, my house is in
shambles...but at the same point. Your husband's accused of being
a serial killer for 30 years and you seem to still kind of really
have the focus on you." This comment hints at Brueski's
skepticism regarding the wife's focus on the destruction of her
home, rather than the grave accusations against her
husband.
 
However, Scott brought in a more empathetic perspective,
commenting on the extensive damage inflicted during such raids.
"It is frustrating to me having seen so many of these raids over
the years...do we have to really destroy the place in the
process?" She emphasized the emotional turmoil the wife must be
going through, adding, "I'd be devastated. I'd be crazy out of my
mind. I'd be upset. I'd be grieving. My life is ruined and damnit
now my home is ruined too, you know?"
 
The discourse took another interesting turn when Brueski pointed
out that the house may have been a "hoarder home" prior to the
raid. He argued that the house's condition was likely already
poor before the search, based on photos showing cluttered boxes
and messy interiors. This raises questions about the necessity of
the level of destruction during the raid, especially if the home
was already in disarray.
 
Scott, reflecting on her expertise in psychology, mentioned the
importance of understanding the living conditions of the family
before the raid. She mused, "It would've been really
interesting...to be able to go through the home without it being
torn up." A sentiment both hosts agreed upon was the challenge
law enforcement must face when searching a hoarder home, given
the sheer amount of items to sift through, especially when
searching for vital evidence like DNA.
 
While Brueski and Scott don't claim expertise on law enforcement
protocol, they touched upon the topic of search warrants. There
was speculation over whether officers could seize items not
specified in the warrant if they seemed relevant to the
investigation. Scott mentioned past instances where evidence
seized outside the scope of a warrant was deemed inadmissible in
court.
 
The podcast episode not only sheds light on the controversies
surrounding law enforcement practices but also emphasizes the
emotional and psychological turmoil families undergo in such
circumstances. As Brueski aptly puts it, the question remains
whether the wife's claim against the police is a legitimate
grievance or if she's, unfortunately, a victim of the
circumstances she found herself in.
 
In a world where the line between justice and intrusion blurs,
episodes like these compel listeners to reflect on the broader
implications of law enforcement actions on individuals and their
families.
Want to listen to ALL of our podcasts AD-FREE? Subscribe
through APPLE PODCASTS, and try it for three days free:
https://tinyurl.com/ycw626tj
Follow Our Other Cases:
https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com
The latest on Catching the Long Island Serial Killer, Chad &
Lori Daybell, The Murder of Ana Walshe, Alex Murdaugh, Bryan
Kohberger, Lucy Letby, Kouri Richins, Justice for Harmony
Montgomery, The Murder of Stephen Smith, The Murder of Madeline
Kingsbury, and much more! Listen at
https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com