Startseite
Podcasts
Giants Shoulder Podcast
#128 - Meet the Neuroscientist Proving Scientists Got Conscious Ai WRONG

#128 - Meet the Neuroscientist Proving Scientists Got Conscious Ai WRONG

Giants Shoulder vor 3 Monaten

0:00

1:50:21

Get Jenni, Your Intelligent Research Assistant (GIANT20 for 20%
off):
http://jenni.ai/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=inf&utm_campaign=thegiantsshoulder

Get the Muse EEG Headband (15% off):
https://choosemuse.com/giantsshoulder

Paul Cisek is a control neuroscientist at the University of
Montreal who records from single neurons in the brains of monkeys
as they think, and who has spent decades reconstructing how the
brain evolved across hundreds of millions of years. His verdict
cuts against everything Silicon Valley believes: the brain was
never a computer — it's a control system built to keep a body
alive, and the most advanced AI on Earth understands nothing it
says.

Expect to learn why Richard Dawkins is wrong that Claude could be
conscious, why every era wrongly compares the brain to its
fanciest technology, how a baseball outfielder reveals what the
brain is really doing, why large language models are "Eliza on
steroids" and 100% illusion, where meaning actually comes from
and why LLMs can never have it, why the real danger isn't ChatGPT
but the agentic systems that come next, whether a paramecium
could be conscious, what Michael Levin's neuron-growing biobots
tell us about minds, and much more…

Timestamps

0:00:00 Trailer

0:02:33 Why Paul Rescheduled to Watch a Monkey Learn

0:06:13 Probing Electrodes Into a Living Brain

0:13:42 What a Single Neuron Actually Sounds Like

0:20:41 The Brain Is Not a Camera Plugged Into a Computer

0:24:55 How an Outfielder Catches a Ball Without Doing Physics

0:33:24 Why Federer "Lets the Cerebellum Run the Show"

0:38:09 Richard Dawkins Says Claude Might Be Conscious

0:39:11 Every Era Thinks the Brain Is Its Latest Gadget

0:42:36 Why AI Is "Eliza on Steroids" and 100% Illusion

0:45:38 The Mechanical Turk and the Stage Magician

0:48:09 The Mimicry Irony at the Heart of Dawkins' Mistake

0:52:32 The One Thing AlphaFold and ChatGPT Both Lack

0:53:30 Where Meaning Actually Comes From

0:57:55 Language Is Persuasion: The Crying Baby Problem

1:03:14 The Paper With Friston and Clark on What AI Misses

1:04:48 Could You Build a Machine That Wants Things?

1:10:23 Build a Mind, Build a Rival: Do We Even Want To?

1:13:32 Is a Paramecium Conscious?

1:18:11 Why There's No Line Between a Lump of Cells and You

1:23:18 Population Thinking: It's All Continuums

1:30:36 The Mad Scientist Won't Be Sam Altman — It'll Be Michael
Levin

1:36:29 Does Synthetic Biology Deserve Its Own Doomsday?1:39:37
Why Real Intelligence Would Be a Competitor We Should Fear

1:43:20 Why the Real World Humbles Every Robot

...

Want a full breakdown of your own conscious inner experience?Join
the Giant's Shoulder community:
https://www.skool.com/the-giants-shoulder-6526/about

Email for sponsorship enquiries: evan@thegiantsshoulder.com...

GS Episodes Mentioned

Paul Cisek Round 1: https://youtu.be/C6frE6nj1tY

Michael Levin — Meet the Scientist Creating New Forms of
Synthetic Life! Dr Michael Levin:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTBZRVKUwyM

Anil Seth — No. 1 Consciousness Expert: Optical Illusions that
Prove Reality is a Lie, Emotions, Books and AI:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOSA06K0l1o

Karl Friston — Meet The Neuroscientist Who Created The Best
Universal Theory Of Brain Function:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R-IZOFs4qmY

Mark Solms — Meet the Scientist Proving Dreams Hold the Key to
Consciousness! Dr Mark Solms:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMWaQ1U6dcc...

Guest Links

Paul Cisek — Faculty page, Université de Montréal:
https://neurosciences.umontreal.ca/en/our-team/staff-directory/staff/cisek-paul/Cisek
Lab: https://www.ciseklab.umontreal.ca/Google Scholar:
https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=Bbk0DEcAAAAJX /
Twitter: https://x.com/PaulCisek...