In this episode, Jovan Maud and Arne Harms discuss Arne's book
'Enduring Erosions: Environmental Displacement and Relocation on
India’s Sinking Coasts', based on his ethnographic research in
the Indian part of the Bengal Delta. This low-lying island region
is highly vulnerable to erosion, storms, saltwater flooding, and
sea-level rise. Harms introduces the concept of “distributed
disaster” to describe coastal erosion. Unlike sudden disasters
such as cyclones or earthquakes, erosion unfolds gradually across
time and space. Residents may lose and rebuild their homes five
to seven times, retreating inland as the coastline advances. For
them, storms are damaging but survivable; the irreversible loss
of land is the real disaster. The book challenges the label
“climate refugee.” Islanders are not simply settled people
suddenly displaced by climate change. Their communities have
longer histories of migration and uprooting, while current
displacement often occurs through small movements within islands
or to nearby areas. Mobility and immobility are closely
connected: families send sons to construction work and daughters
to domestic work elsewhere so that remittances can allow
relatives to remain on the islands. Arne uses “the thinning of
life” to describe both ecological decline and shrinking human
possibilities. Saltwater kills trees, makes farmland
unproductive, and leaves ruined landscapes. At the same time,
falling land values, homelessness, declining livelihoods, and
perceived state abandonment reduce people’s prospects for a
secure future. The state plays a contradictory role. Residents
blame port infrastructure for redirecting tides and worsening
erosion, while authorities selectively build strong protections
around strategically important port assets. Elsewhere,
communities receive temporary mud-and-wood embankments that must
be rebuilt repeatedly. This demonstrates that the state has the
capacity to protect land but chooses which places and interests
to prioritize. The conversation also emphasizes multiple,
overlapping temporalities: tides, monsoons, repeated rebuilding,
gradual retreat, personal histories of displacement, and
expectations about when particular fields or homes will
disappear. Residents live with both uncertainty about the
islands’ long-term future and precise knowledge of which places
are likely to be lost soon. Arne hopes the ethnography will
encourage humanitarian and disaster-response systems to recognize
slow, recurring erosion—not only dramatic events—as disaster.
Although climate change may eventually make large parts of the
delta uninhabitable, he rejects simplistic calls for the mass
relocation of millions. Instead, he advocates better concepts and
more just forms of assistance for people living through
environmental decline that has become part of everyday life
rather than an exceptional event.
Kommentare (0)
Melde dich an, um einen Kommentar zu schreiben.