In episode 61 of the Counselling Tutor Podcast, Ken Kelly and Rory
Lees-Oakes explain the difference between ethical dilemmas and
ethical conflicts, and how you can deal with these. 'Theory with
Rory' looks at rackets and stamps, part of transactional analysis
(TA) theory. Finally, the presenters illustrate the id, ego and
superego (part of psychodynamic theory). Ethical Dilemmas versus
Ethical Conflicts (starts at 2.40 mins) What is the difference
between an ethical dilemma and an ethical conflict? Rory explains
that an ethical conflict occurs when two things 'bump into each
other and you know it'. For example, an ethical conflict would
exist if you offered to counsel a colleague or your partner,
because there would be a dual relationship, which the Ethical
Framework for the Counselling Professions of the British
Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) cautions
against: 'We will establish and maintain appropriate professional
and personal boundaries in our relationships with clients by
ensuring that … any dual or multiple relationships will be avoided
where the risks of harm to the client outweigh any benefits to the
client' (BACP, 2015: 8). Ken gives another example of an ethical
conflict: when your agency's operating procedures conflict with
those advocated in the BACP's Ethical Framework. Some drugs and
alcohol agencies, for example, require counsellors to tell them if
a client is using substances - in other words, they have different
rules on limits to confidentiality. Ethical conflicts can often be
resolved by careful contracting, if you explain accurately and
openly what is on offer and the client accepts that. If you, as a
counsellor, feel unhappy with an agency's operating procedures,
don't be afraid to try to get these changed or to decide you can't
work for that agency. Rory describes how some of his students
raised their concerns with their agency (about the contract) and
got this changed; the agency was delighted to have engaged and
proactive counsellors on-board. Ethical dilemmas, meanwhile,
require you to think through a difficult situation where the answer
is not clear-cut. In other words, you need to make a 'judgement
call'. Two examples of ethical dilemmas might be: A client arrives
at an appointment, having driven there. You can see they are under
the influence of alcohol. Do you report them to the police? Your
agency asks you to counsel a client in a room that is clearly not
soundproof. Do you go ahead? The most important thing when faced
with an ethical dilemma is to think it through carefully: you need
to make sure that whatever decision you make is defensible.
Ultimately, it is about courage and candour. It can help to phone
the ethics department of the BACP; another useful resource is Tim
Bond's ethical problem-solving matrix. You can download this here,
or it is also available in the Handouts Vault and Counselling Study
Resource (CSR). Rackets and Stamps in TA (starts at 13.32) You may
know someone who is prone to suddenly 'blowing up': becoming angry
at something that seems to you nothing, or very trivial. This can
be confusing or frightening for those on the receiving end, or
those around the angry person. TA has a theory that may explain
what is happening here. In TA, a racket occurs when a child
replaces an authentic feeling with one that's more socially
acceptable to their parents. This becomes part of the child's life
script and they no longer feel the authentic emotion. People who
hide or restrict their real feelings tend to keep these as bad
memories - and accumulate them as you might stamps on a supermarket
loyalty card. Then, every so often they 'cash in' these stamps by
having an angry outburst. Some people may save up their stamps for
a day - and others for years - on their emotional legacy card. You
can download a handout on racket feelings and stamp collecting
here, or from the Handouts Vault or CSR (where you can also find
Rory's lecture on TA). Id, Ego and Superego (starts at 16.20 mins)
These concepts come from the psychoanalytical theory of Sigmund
Freud, the father of talking therapies. Freud believed in drive
theory: that the human psyche controlled by biological drives. Rory
compares the id, ego and superego to the child, adult and parent in
TA (though in psychodynamic theory, the superego relates more to
societal than to individual values). He illustrates the three
concepts using an image suggested by fellow tutor Glenys Arthur. If
faced with a large chocolate cake, each component of the self might
act as follows: Id: 'I want to eat all that cake - now!' Superego:
'That would be so bad for your health. You really should have some
fruit instead.' Ego: 'I know you want to eat it all, and it's true
that wouldn't be good for your health. But you need some treats in
life. So why not enjoy one slice?'
Kommentare (0)
Melde dich an, um einen Kommentar zu schreiben.